WWE’s Cathy Kelley may have her sights set on a new television gig, and this one has nothing to do with wrestling. With Maya Jama stepping down as host of Love Island UK, Kelley is already showing interest in taking over the popular dating show.
Jama announced her departure on November 8, 2026, revealing on Instagram that she’s leaving Love Island UK after hosting nine series since 2023. The 32-year-old reflected on her time with the show and explained that she’s ready to move on.
“What an incredible era and what an unforgettable time I’ve had, it’s been far too much fun to put into words or a video but as all good things must come to an end, it’s my time to step down as the host of my beloved Love Island.”
Jama took over from Laura Whitmore in 2023 and went on to become the face of the series, including appearances on Love Island All Stars and Love Island Games. She thanked everyone who supported her during the run.
“I started hosting the show aged 28 and during the 9 incredible series met the most wonderful humans along the way. I’ve loved every slow-mo walk, fire pit and live show. I’ll forever be grateful for the experience.”
Now, WWE’s Cathy Kelley wants a shot at the job. Kelley is ready to throw her name into the mix following Jama’s departure. While there’s no indication that ITV has approached her about replacing Jama, the WWE personality certainly has plenty of experience in front of the camera.
The timing is interesting because WWE has already been looking to expand Cathy Kelley’s role beyond backstage interviews. In August, it emerged that the company was impressed with her work and wanted to explore additional opportunities for her across WWE programming and digital platforms. Kelley has also explored television opportunities outside wrestling. She previously revealed that she turned down a chance to host a food show for USA Network because of the unusual demands of the program.
Whether Kelley actually gets considered for Love Island UK remains to be seen, but she’s clearly interested in the opportunity. With Jama officially leaving and ITV needing a new host, Kelley wouldn’t mind swapping WWE backstage interviews for the Love Island villa.
Would you like to see Cathy Kelley become the next host of Love Island UK, or should she stick with WWE? Please share your thoughts and feedback in the comment section below.
