Johnny Gargano might have found his ticket into the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and the crazy part is that Marvel already created a character who looks suspiciously like him. The WWE Superstar has now made it clear that he’s interested in playing that character if Marvel ever decides to bring him to the screen. Considering Gargano previously called out Marvel over the character’s striking resemblance to him, this could be one of the strangest casting pitches to come from a WWE wrestler.
During a November 20, 2026 interview with TV Insider, Gargano discussed his love of Marvel and WWE’s upcoming collaboration with Disney. The conversation eventually turned to whether he could imagine himself portraying a Marvel character in a movie.
Gargano didn’t name an established superhero like Captain America or Spider-Man. Instead, he brought up Repent, a mutant character introduced in Marvel’s X-Men comics who already has an unusual connection to the former NXT Champion. When asked whether he could see himself playing a particular Marvel character, Gargano made it clear that he’s open to the opportunity.
“I can never see myself as someone. But there was a character introduced in a Marvel comic book recently [Repent]. If he ever makes it on screen, we’ll see if I posted about it, I think as well. Look, I’m always open to it, I’d love to do it. If it happens, that’d be great.”
There’s actually some history behind Gargano bringing up Repent. As Ringside News previously covered, Gargano took to social media on August 27, 2026, after noticing that the newly introduced X-Men character looked remarkably similar to him. Repent’s black-and-red appearance, facial hair, and overall design immediately reminded Gargano of himself. He even tagged Marvel in his post while drawing attention to the resemblance.
At the time, there was no indication that Gargano had any involvement with creating the character. Marvel also had not provided an explanation connecting the wrestler to Repent’s design. Now, however, Gargano is going a step further by openly expressing interest in playing the mutant if the character ever makes it into a live-action production.
The timing is especially interesting because WWE is preparing for a major crossover with Marvel. The companies are scheduled to present an Avengers: Doomsday-themed Worlds Collide event on December 15, featuring WWE and AAA talent. Gargano was also asked whether he had any special Marvel-inspired wrestling gear planned for the event. He explained that the collaboration has opened the door to ideas he’s wanted to explore for years.
“Look, the fact now that it’s on the table, the fact that there’s actually a collab…I’ve been dreaming of this for a while since the black and gold era of NXT. There’s things I have in the back of my head that would be really, really cool, really, really awesome. We’ll see if it happens. But yes, obviously, being a big comic book nerd, being a big Marvel nerd, there’s tons of things I feel like I can whip up and do justice for this awesome event”
Gargano’s obsession with Marvel goes well beyond wrestling gear. Ringside News also covered how his WWE travel schedule has forced him to make special arrangements to watch new Marvel releases before spoilers start circulating online.
For now, there is no indication that Marvel Studios has contacted Gargano about playing Repent or that the character is even being considered for a movie. However, Gargano has already spotted a Marvel character who looks like him, publicly questioned the resemblance, and now admitted he’d love the opportunity to portray him. If Marvel ever needs someone to bring Repent to life, Gargano certainly isn’t being subtle about his interest.
What do you think about Johnny Gargano wanting to play Marvel’s Repent in a future movie? How well do you think the WWE Superstar could pull off the character if Marvel actually gave him the opportunity? Let us know your thoughts and leave your feedback in the comments below.