Sheamus and Drew McIntyre looked like they had something cooking after the infamous “burger after burger” promo took off. Apparently they actually did — but according to Sheamus, whatever WWE had planned for the two simply never happened.
Speaking on the Strength Required podcast with Tom Degan and Cory Perkins, Sheamus revealed that he and McIntyre were supposed to move into a storyline together following their viral exchange. Instead, Sheamus says he suddenly disappeared from television and never even received another in-ring promo.
“And I never after, I never got another in-ring promo again. It was crazy. It was like, we killed it and then it was supposed to, me and Drew were supposed to go into this thing and then I just disappeared.”
What makes that even crazier is that the line that helped get everyone talking was Sheamus’ idea in the first place. After returning to WWE carrying more weight than usual and getting absolutely destroyed online for his physique, Sheamus decided to lean into the jokes rather than run from them.
“So I came back and I got torn apart, dude. I got torn apart. I got torn apart. Like the belly, the people, there was like a lot of creative people out there who made me look even bigger than what I was.”
Sheamus wasn’t particularly offended by any of it either. He felt that if wrestlers are happy accepting praise when they look great, they also have to be prepared for people to come after them when they don’t.
“But I leaned into it. Like, I just like, I leaned right into it. Yeah. You have to, like, it’s entertainment. Exactly. Yeah. Listen, if you’re going to be praised when you’re in great shape, you have to take the stick when you’re not. And that’s really important.”
He also made it clear that being in the public eye means people are going to have opinions whether you like them or not. For Sheamus, accepting only the positive side of that attention doesn’t really work.
“I don’t understand people who are like, they just want to hear the positive things. If you’re in the limelight and you’re okay with taking all this positive praise and everything, you can’t reject the negative criticism. You just can’t. It comes with it. Like everyone’s going to have an opinion and you put yourself in that position.”
That’s where McIntyre entered the picture. Sheamus saw all the burger jokes going around and decided his real-life best friend should use one of them against him during their upcoming promo.
“So the second week I had a promo. Best mates in the business is Drew, Drew McIntyre, and I was like, dude, I just had this burger, I said a burger, I saw a burger thing everywhere.”
Sheamus specifically handed McIntyre the “burger after burger” line, but Drew initially didn’t want to do it. He apparently needed some convincing before roasting his friend on WWE television.
“So I fed him the line. I said, just say, just use that burger after burger line. And he was like, I can’t do that. I said, buddy, bro, do it. I’m telling you, you can do it.”
McIntyre eventually listened, and Sheamus remembers the reaction being exactly what he’d hoped for. The line took off immediately and everyone got a laugh out of it.
“And he did it. And it just went everywhere. And then I had to wrestle a match after. But it was great and everyone laughed. It was good craic.”
The strange part came afterwards. Despite Sheamus believing they “killed it” and saying he and Drew were supposed to go into something together, there was no next chapter for him on television. That whole period had actually started with another WWE plan that didn’t happen. Sheamus had been working himself into great shape while pushing hard for a WrestleMania match against Gunther, believing their previous chemistry and his pursuit of the Intercontinental Championship gave WWE an obvious story.
“But then I was pushing for this Mania match with a guy called Gunther. We’d had a couple of two great matches before, and it was a Mania match coming up, and I felt great, and I was looking great. And I was like, look, I kept pushing for this match at Mania. I’m good to go. I’m good to go. And then in the end, it just didn’t go my way. They went a different direction.”
Sheamus felt there was a natural payoff because the Intercontinental Championship was the one title his character had never won. WWE went another way at WrestleMania despite him making repeated calls trying to get the match.
“No, but I think it would have been awesome. Like, it would have been great. We had great, great chemistry, and there was a story there, and how he had this belt, this Intercontinental title belt that I never won. And he ended up losing at Mania, and like, it would have been a great finish. It was the only title that the character had never won.
So I pushed and pushed and pushed. I made so many calls, pushed, and it just didn’t happen. So I was like, you know what, screw it. And I just kind of took my foot off the gas and I just started like, whatever. Had a couple pints of Guinness. I just kind of, I just kind of like, whatever. I’m not going to stress about it. I’m just going to enjoy my life.”
Sheamus thought he’d still have another month to dial everything back in before returning, but WWE suddenly called him earlier than expected. That left him coming back heavier than he’d planned.
“And then I was supposed to come back at a later date and I got called early to come back. So, cuz I just like, I’ll get, I’ve got another month to go. I’ll just dial it in the next. But then I got a call, so I had to go back early and I was carrying a lot of weight.”
The biker shorts he was wearing certainly didn’t help matters either. Even Sheamus agreed they weren’t exactly doing him any favors.
“I was also wearing these, what you call them? They’re like biker shorts.”
When the host joked about all the Guinness and burgers, Sheamus fired back: “Yeah. Even without the burgers, they did not look good.” Ironically, WWE not following through with the Drew program ended up giving Sheamus another kick in the ass. He said that period pushed him toward changing his training approach with Ladder and eventually getting himself back into great shape.
“But I will tell you after that situation, that’s when, that’s when I jumped back on Ladder. That’s when Isabella was like telling me the Ladder stuff and that’s when I jumped into it. So that was like, that kind of ended up then when I went through the tour and stuff, but that kind of, that was what catapulted me towards using Ladder and that’s where all the journey started and that’s when I got back in great shape.”
So the “burger after burger” promo wasn’t just Drew McIntyre getting a hilarious line in at his friend’s expense. Sheamus says they were actually supposed to go somewhere with it, only for him to disappear from television before that next chapter ever happened.
What do you think WWE could have done with Sheamus and Drew McIntyre after their viral promo? Let us know in the comments.
This transcript was produced exclusively for Ringside News from the original recording. Republishing the transcription in full is prohibited. When using excerpts, provide prominent credit and a link to this article.