The Undertaker spent decades terrifying people inside a WWE ring, but apparently, he was also giving future WWE Superstars nightmares. NXT star Shiloh Hill just admitted that The Deadman’s entrance scared him so badly as a child that he would actually cry. The craziest part is that the same man who once terrified Hill eventually became his personal mentor on WWE television.
During an appearance on Good Karma Wrestling, Hill was asked about working alongside wrestling legends who had once seemed larger than life to him. He explained that being around those personalities still doesn’t feel entirely real, comparing his WWE experience to stepping inside a video game.
“Yeah, no it’s mind blowing. I’ve said so many times that I keep feeling like I’m in 2K, like I’m in like a very realistic version of 2K.”
Hill then brought up The Undertaker, revealing that his childhood reaction to the WWE legend was a lot more intense than simply being intimidated by his character.
“For me what the Undertaker was one like growing up I was like I was terrified of the Undertaker. I now I really like as I got older I started to really appreciate him as a character, but when I first started wrestling or watching wrestling I was like when the Undertaker would make his entrance I would like cry.”
Hill explained that those childhood memories made their eventual working relationship almost impossible to believe.
“I was so scared. So to be like on LFG with him as my like mentor and coach on that show was it was very surreal.”
This wasn’t just a brief meeting with a childhood idol, either. Hill became a member of Team Undertaker on WWE LFG, and The Undertaker previously gave Hill a massive endorsement after watching his intense reaction to a promo challenge. The WWE legend called Hill “money,” making it clear that he saw something special in the young wrestler.
That relationship eventually paid off when Hill won WWE LFG Season 2 and secured an NXT contract in October 2025. And The Undertaker wasn’t the only WWE legend leaving Hill feeling like he had stepped into an alternate reality. He admitted that having conversations with Shawn Michaels still gives him the same surreal feeling.
“Obviously like talking to Shawn Michaels face to face is like it feels like it’s like a 2K backstage scene or something.”
Hill has gone from crying whenever The Undertaker made his entrance to learning directly from the man himself. That’s a pretty insane career turnaround, especially considering the same intimidating character that once scared him became one of the people responsible for helping him reach WWE NXT.
What do you think about Shiloh Hill admitting that The Undertaker used to make him cry as a child before eventually becoming his mentor? Let us know your thoughts and feedback in the comments below.
This transcript was produced exclusively for Ringside News from the original recording. Republishing the transcription in full is prohibited. When using excerpts, provide prominent credit and a link to this article.