Jonathan Coachman Calls Jade Cargill Overpaid and Questions Her Star Power After NXT Rant

Subhojeet Mukherjee 7 min read
Follow
Us
To Stay Connected With Our Updates

Jade Cargill has made it painfully clear that she’s tired of hearing people tell her she should have gone to NXT. Jonathan Coachman and Vince Russo heard her response, and neither guy exactly came away convinced that shutting down the conversation was the right move.

Speaking on The Coach & Bro Show, Coachman started with Cargill’s claim that she makes too much money not to be seen on WWE television. He sarcastically admitted there was one part of her rant he actually agreed with.

“Number one, I do agree with her on one thing she said there, Vince. She does make too much money. She does make too much money.”

Coachman then zeroed in on Cargill telling people who don’t like her to simply turn around when she appears on television. He wondered how Vince McMahon would have reacted to one of his wrestlers basically telling viewers they don’t have to watch.

“Can you imagine Vince McMahon watching a video of a talent saying, ‘If you don’t like me, turn around and look at the back wall’? Can you imagine an entire audience on camera doing that? How pissed would he be?”

The conversation then moved to Cargill saying her name generates money, and Coachman questioned what that statement actually means in professional wrestling. He used The Rock, CM Punk and Cody Rhodes as examples of wrestlers whose names translate directly into business.

“And the other part of this, and this is I imagine sitting there watching the show with all the stars when she says, ‘My name makes money’ or ‘My name is money.’”

Russo immediately jumped on that particular comment and saw it as a major mistake, saying, “That’s the death knell. Death knell.” Coachman kept going and explained why he had such an issue with the claim. In his view, saying your name equals money means being able to move merchandise and sell tickets.

“Because in wrestling, Vince, when you say my name equals money, what does that mean from a wrestling perspective? If a talent like Rock or Punk or Cody say my name equals money, that means they sell what?”

Russo answered: “Merch.” Coachman then said:“And they sell tickets.” Russo saw the entire situation as part of a bigger problem. He argued that some wrestlers simply aren’t being taught enough about how the wrestling business traditionally works, and he believes there aren’t enough people around them willing to explain it.

“They don’t understand, bro. They don’t understand. They don’t get it, coach. And there’s nobody smartening them up.”

That brought them straight back to the NXT argument Cargill wants everyone to stop having. Coachman questioned whether she understands some of wrestling’s older locker-room traditions, including what it means to be the wrestler whose name is actually drawing people into the building.

“Do you think she understands what it means to be on the marquee? Do you think she understands what ‘thanks for the house’ means?”

Russo didn’t hesitate: “No.” Interestingly, Russo didn’t put all of that on Cargill herself. He argued that if nobody ever taught her those parts of the business, then the bigger question is why she was placed in that position without receiving that education in the first place.

“But again, coach, whose fault is it? Because listen, she doesn’t understand all that. She’s not been educated on that. She’s not been schooled on that. So, if she’s not been schooled and educated on that, why is she there? That’s why she should have went to NXT. So, she would have learned all the things that we’re talking about. So, whose fault really is it?”

Coachman wasn’t willing to completely blame Cargill or WWE for that one. He split responsibility right down the middle.

“I think it’s 50/50, to be honest with you.”

Coachman then brought up Cargill’s experience level, arguing that it makes the NXT discussion even harder to dismiss. He referenced another interview where Cargill talked about how recently she started wrestling and questioned how that squares with presenting herself as someone who never needed developmental.

“The problem is, Vince, she just went on another podcast a couple months ago and says, ‘I just had my first match three years ago.’ But yet you’re a mega star and you don’t need NXT when you tell the world that you have been wrestling less than four years.”

Coachman then cited Cargill’s previous explanation of how unusual the beginning of her career actually was. Unlike wrestlers who spent years working independent shows before reaching national television, Cargill’s learning process happened in front of a huge audience.

“My first match ever was on TV. I didn’t go through the indies. I didn’t do all that. My NXT was AEW.”

Coachman also wanted to make one thing clear — this isn’t coming from some personal bad experience with Cargill. He said he’s never even met her, but her public response to criticism still gets under his skin.

“Vince, it’s not that I don’t know her. I’ve never met her. I think it’s my OG in me. She bugs me because she does BS like this.”

He then compared Cargill’s approach with other established wrestlers who could brag about their status but choose not to. Coachman believes maintaining relationships backstage matters, and he claimed comments like these can work against someone when it comes to receiving opportunities.

“And there’s so many other stars that legitimately could say that. And they don’t, cuz they know they want to get along with everybody backstage. They know they want to get the push. And if you do this, you’re not getting the push. She’s never gotten a push other than money.”

That is Coachman’s assessment rather than confirmation of any actual WWE decision regarding Cargill. Russo then offered his own interpretation of why he believes Cargill reacted so strongly to people criticizing her work.

“But also, coach, what that tells you is that she has a very deep sense of insecurity. So, while she’s cutting that promo on the fan, she’s also reminding herself of how great she is and how good she looks because she’s insecure because they’re making all these comments about her work.”

Russo continued by arguing that wrestlers have to learn how to ignore that kind of criticism. In his view, constantly engaging with it only makes the situation worse.

“I mean, that’s where it stems from. But that’s where you got to be smart enough to — bro, if you can’t ignore that stuff, you shouldn’t be in the freaking business.”

Coachman then turned his attention to Cargill reading social media comments in the first place. He argued that telling wrestling fans to stop talking about you is basically an invitation for them to do the exact opposite.

“So, why would she go in and read? Clearly, she reads her mentions. Clearly, she’s like, ‘Stop talking about me. Stop talking about me.’ So, what’s a wrestling fan going to do?”

Russo had a pretty obvious answer: “Talk about her.” Coachman then predicted that the response could go beyond people simply talking about Cargill. He suggested fans could start compiling footage specifically highlighting mistakes from her matches.

“And they’re probably going to put together a video of all of her botched spots she’s had this year.”

Coachman took that criticism even further by claiming Cargill’s mistakes during major matches are another reason she hasn’t been pushed more heavily. Again, that’s Coachman’s own assessment of her WWE booking rather than a reported explanation from anyone within the company.

“That’s the other reason she hasn’t been pushed because every time she gets into a big match, she messes something up.”

Coachman insisted he wasn’t saying that simply because he dislikes Cargill. He told listeners to go back and watch the footage themselves.

“That’s just fact. That’s not me hating. That’s fact. Go watch the video.”

Cargill clearly doesn’t believe strangers should dictate how her career should have unfolded, while Coachman and Russo think publicly fighting those strangers is only keeping the criticism alive. At this point, the NXT debate she wants dead seems to have gotten another life entirely.

Do you think Jonathan Coachman and Vince Russo have a point about Jade Cargill’s NXT comments, or should people finally move on from debating her developmental path? Let us know in the comments.

This transcript was produced exclusively for Ringside News from the original recording. Republishing the transcription in full is prohibited. When using excerpts, provide prominent credit and a link to this article.

Share Send This Story To Your Friends
Subhojeet Mukherjee

Subhojeet Mukherjee

Subhojeet Mukherjee has covered pro wrestling for over 20 years, delivering trusted news and backstage updates to fans around the world.