Zoey Stark’s WWE Return Uncertain as Knee Injury May Sideline Her Through 2025

Zoey Stark’s WWE career has just hit a major roadblock—and the news keeps getting tougher.

According to Fightful Select, the knee injury Stark suffered during the May 19 episode of WWE Raw is far more serious than initially expected. While she’s seemingly indicated via social media that surgery is in her future, backstage reports now suggest WWE is preparing to be without her for the rest of the year.

“The WWE Raw star sustained a knee injury on May 19, in a gruesome sight,” the report states. “She was removed from the match and helped to the back. She also noted on Twitter that she wouldn’t be able to perform for quite some time.”

The early belief among those backstage is that Stark may have suffered a tear requiring surgery, though an official diagnosis has not yet been publicly confirmed. Still, WWE officials are reportedly bracing for a long recovery timeline—possibly extending through the end of 2025.

The injury took place just moments into Stark’s Women’s Money in the Bank qualifying triple threat match with Rhea Ripley and Kairi Sane. She was pulled from the bout during a commercial break and escorted backstage. The match outcome had to be rewritten on the fly, and Sane was unexpectedly pinned—something not originally planned for her return.

In a heartfelt tweet posted on May 21, Stark addressed her fans directly: “Wow the love and support means more to me than you’ll ever know! What hurts more than my knee is knowing I won’t be able to perform for all of you for a while… As the saying goes, the comeback is greater than the setback. Love you guys.”

As of now, no official return timeline has been shared by WWE, but this injury is clearly more than just a temporary setback—it could sideline one of Raw’s rising stars for the long haul.

Do you think WWE should keep Zoey Stark in storylines while she recovers? How big of a loss is this for the women’s division? Sound off in the comments and let us know your thoughts.