CM Punk Won’t Reveal What AJ Styles Said About His WWE Exit

With AJ Styles’ WWE in-ring career officially in the rearview mirror, speculation about his next move is heating up—especially with All Elite Wrestling and New Japan Pro Wrestling reportedly watching closely. But now, CM Punk has added fuel to the fire with a cryptic comment that’s sure to keep fans guessing.

Appearing on The Pat McAfee Show, Punk was asked directly whether he believed AJ Styles was truly retired. Instead of confirming or denying anything, Punk gave a knowing but guarded answer:

“Who knows? I don’t know. I know what he told me behind the scenes, which is nobody else’s business.”

That single line has instantly reignited conversation about whether Styles’ Royal Rumble match was a true farewell—or just the end of his WWE chapter.

The timing is notable. According to Fightful Select, Styles was a major topic of conversation backstage at AEW Dynamite on January 28, just days before his retirement became public. While no official offer has been confirmed, the belief within AEW is unanimous: if Styles is available, they want him.

“As of February 3, we have not been told that an offer is made, but it was universally expected among AEW sources that if AEW is able to, they would bring in Styles.”

The speculation doesn’t end there. NJPW is also reportedly eyeing Styles amid a wave of recent talent exits, hoping to rekindle his legacy in Japan if he’s interested in returning.

But perhaps the most telling detail came from a source close to Styles:

“AJ will do what he wants to do regardless of money, and he’s in a position to do so.”

And if CM Punk’s comment is any indication, that decision might already be made—privately.

Should AEW go all-in on pursuing AJ Styles? Or was Royal Rumble the perfect ending to an all-time great career? Drop your take in the comments and let us know what you think Punk’s silence really means.