Bayley Says Wrestlers Trying Too Hard to Play Characters Can Hurt Their Performances

H Jenkins 5 min read
Follow
Us
To Stay Connected With Our Updates

Bayley has some advice for wrestlers who think they need to completely reinvent themselves to get over, and it might not be what they want to hear. The WWE veteran believes that trying too hard to act like a professional wrestler can actually work against someone, especially when audiences can tell they’re just going through the motions.

During the November 18, 2026 debut episode of The AJ Styles Podcast, Bayley joined Styles and Just Jay to discuss her career, professional wrestling and helping the next generation of talent. The conversation eventually turned to what advice she would give independent wrestlers trying to make it to WWE, and Bayley explained that one of the biggest breakthroughs in her own career came when she stopped overthinking how she was supposed to act.

Before offering her advice, Bayley discussed her Camp LODESTONE initiative, which gives independent women wrestlers opportunities to train and learn from experienced performers. As Ringside News previously covered, Bayley has personally invested in helping aspiring wrestlers develop their skills and find opportunities in the business.

When Styles asked what advice she would give someone trying to make it to the top, Bayley admitted that narrowing everything down to one lesson wasn’t easy. However, she eventually explained that connecting with her actual emotions played a major role in her development during her early NXT career.

“It is hard because I struggle between the main thing that I think at least that helped me when I really started to understand things and when I started getting booked with NXT more or whatever was just like, I just followed my gut and let out my actual feelings of how happy this made me and how much I felt during matches or whatever, because sometimes we tried so hard to be this character or this wrestler and we’re trying like, okay, this is what a bad guy would do. This is what a good guy would do. This is what this coach wants from me or this.”

Bayley explained that things started falling into place once she stopped constantly worrying about what a particular character was supposed to do and started drawing from her own feelings instead.

“But I’m like, the more I tuned into everything, my raw emotion and could channel that into whatever character or position I was in, I felt like it…”

According to Bayley, audiences are much better at recognizing genuine emotion than some wrestlers might realize. She believes people can tell when someone is truly enjoying themselves in the ring, and they can also spot when a performer is putting on an act that doesn’t feel real.

“Because the fans could feel everything. You know, I’m watching as a fan or just a friend or whatever, I can tell when the person in the ring is truly having fun or is truly enjoying what they’re doing. I can tell when they’re faking it too.”

Bayley acknowledged that explaining this to younger wrestlers isn’t necessarily easy because the advice can sound obvious. However, she made it clear that there’s a difference between genuinely feeling something in the ring and simply convincing yourself that you’re doing it.

“And I feel like that’s hard advice to give to some people because it just sounds like, okay, but obviously I really feel it. I’m doing it. There’s like, no, but I don’t know how to explain it.”

Styles jumped in and offered his own interpretation of what Bayley was trying to explain. He suggested that being an effective wrestling character doesn’t necessarily require someone to invent an entirely different personality. Instead, it can be about turning up the volume on who they already are.

“When you’re out there, you’re basically, whether you’re a heel or a baby face, your Pam turned all the way up.”

Styles continued by pointing out that Bayley’s wrestling persona works because it comes from her actual personality rather than something completely manufactured.

“So it doesn’t require a lot of thinking about what would Bayley do because it is you and people can see that when it’s not authentic. So I don’t know if that’s what you’re trying to say, but that’s kind of how I feel about it.”

Bayley agreed with Styles’ explanation, although she acknowledged that wrestlers still need to develop recognizable characters that stand out from everyone else.

“Yeah, it’s hard to explain when there’s so many, you know, also, you want to have a character that stands out too, you know, a promotion or WWE. So it’s hard to say that, but yeah, that’s a big thinker to give one piece of advice.”

It’s an interesting perspective coming from someone who has gone through several major character changes during her WWE career. Bayley initially became popular with her cheerful Hugger persona before transitioning into a much more aggressive heel character. She previously explained how she used genuine frustrations from her career to fuel that transformation rather than simply pretending to be angry.

Her character has continued evolving since then, including the return of elements of her original Hugger persona during WWE RAW in September 2025. Those changes give Bayley plenty of firsthand experience with the challenge of creating a distinctive character without losing the person underneath it.

Bayley’s advice essentially comes down to something that sounds simple but can be difficult to pull off. Wrestlers can spend years developing their characters, studying promos and trying to figure out what audiences want, but if the emotions behind everything feel fake, all that effort might not matter. For Bayley, sometimes the best character is just the real person with the volume turned all the way up.

What do you think about Bayley’s belief that audiences can tell when wrestlers are faking their emotions, and which WWE stars do you think do the best job of bringing their real personalities into their characters? Let us know your thoughts and leave your feedback in the comments below.

This transcript was produced exclusively for Ringside News from the original recording. Republishing the transcription in full is prohibited. When using excerpts, provide prominent credit and a link to this article.

Share Send This Story To Your Friends
H Jenkins

H Jenkins

H Jenkins has been breaking pro wrestling news on Ringside News for nearly a decade, with his reports featured by TMZ, Forbes, The Sun, and more.