With WWE Royal Rumble 2025 just around the corner, speculation over surprise entrants is at an all-time high. From returning legends to rising stars, multiple names have been spotted in Indianapolis, fueling rumors about who might show up in one of WWE’s most unpredictable matches. While nothing is confirmed, here’s what we know so far about the possible surprises heading into the big event.
Nikki Bella has officially been spotted in town for Royal Rumble weekend, and fans are already wondering if she’s set for an in-ring return. While the WWE Hall of Famer hasn’t competed since her one-night comeback in the 2022 Women’s Royal Rumble, she’s maintained close ties with WWE, recently attending the Raw on Netflix premiere. When asked if she and Brie Bella could return, she didn’t shut the door. “Will we ever see the Bella Twins back? Good question. I just may be here looking at my competition soon, so stay tuned.”
It’s unclear if Nikki is here for a Rumble spot or just to support friends, but her presence in Indianapolis has fans paying attention.
Former WWE stars Matt Cardona and Mickie James were both seen at WWE’s hotel in Indianapolis on Friday. Cardona, who’s been vocal about a potential WWE return, has teased Royal Rumble appearances in the past, and with his wife Chelsea Green currently holding the WWE United States Championship, a comeback wouldn’t be shocking.
Mickie James being in town is just as intriguing. The former WWE Women’s Champion made history in 2022 as the first active Knockouts Champion to enter the Royal Rumble while still signed with TNA. With her husband Nick Aldis now working as SmackDown’s General Manager and her involvement in WWE’s upcoming “LFG” series, there’s a good chance she’s here for more than just a visit.
Another major name floating around is Jordynne Grace, who was reportedly spotted at the Indianapolis airport. Grace quickly downplayed the speculation, posting on social media that she’s headed to Texas for her mother’s 50th birthday. But given her history of keeping secrets before big moments, some fans aren’t convinced she’s skipping the Rumble.
Earlier reports indicated that Stephanie Vaquer’s name has been “discussed” for a potential Royal Rumble spot. The Chilean wrestler, who made her mark in CMLL and NJPW before signing with WWE’s NXT brand, has been gaining attention as a standout performer. A surprise appearance in the Rumble could be the perfect way to introduce her to a bigger audience and set up a future main roster run.
Another interesting name to keep an eye on is Roxanne Perez. The former NXT Women’s Champion is reportedly in Indianapolis for the event, though it’s unclear if she’ll enter the Rumble. With WWE expected to stack the women’s match with surprise entrants, Perez’s presence suggests she could be on the verge of making the jump to Raw or SmackDown.
Another interesting name making the rounds is Rhyno. The former WWE and ECW Champion was reportedly seen at WWE’s hotel in Indianapolis, where he was greeted by Talent Relations staff before being “quickly whisked away to a more private area.” With his recent departure from TNA Wrestling, speculation is growing that he could be set for a surprise return in the men’s Royal Rumble match. While he was already in town for WrestleCon, his presence at the WWE hotel suggests there might be more to the story.
With all these names floating around, WWE is clearly setting up some surprises for this year’s Royal Rumble. Whether it’s returning legends, NXT standouts, or potential crossover moments with TNA, there are plenty of possibilities.
Who do you think will make a surprise appearance? Could Nikki Bella, Matt Cardona, or Mickie James be stepping back into a WWE ring? Drop your predictions in the comments!